No, Thank You. I’d Rather Not Trade For Jeff Samardzija


Jeff Samardzija Cubs

Jeff Samardzija Cubs – Photo Credit: Mike LaChance

A few weeks back, I wrote about potential trade targets for the San Francisco Giants. James Shields, Jeff Samardzija, and Jed Lowrie. One of them was more obvious than the others, and that same one has recently had a number of articles and news pieces surface regarding him and the San Francisco Giants. Yes, we’re talking about Samardzija. I was a supporter of bring Samardzija to the Giants in my last article.

And I take back everything I said.

Samardzija is having a great year, there’s no denying that. Over his first 15 games in 2014 he’s thrown 97 innings and sports a 2.60 ERA and 1.206 WHIP with an 8.4 K/9. Those ERA and WHIP are on pace to be the best of his career, and not just by a little. Samardzija’s holds a career 3.96 ERA and 1.33 WHIP.  

So maybe, you might think, he’s really taken steps forward, and this is going to be a career year for him. This improvement is legit, you say. Maybe you buy it.

But you know what? I don’t.

Samardzija has a history of starting strong and then falling off as the season goes on. And it really isn’t hard to see. In April and May of 2013, Samardzija started 11 games. He totaled 72.2 innings with a 2.86 ERA, 1.05 WHIP and an awesome 9.95 K/9. But his numbers from June till the end of the year (22 starts)? 141 innings, 5.10 ERA, 1.50 WHIP and a (still good, but not as good) 8.55 K/9.

He’s already on pace for that again this year. Let’s take a look at the numbers side-by-side.

April/May (11 starts) of 2014: 1.68 ERA, 1.06 WHIP, 7.68 K/9
June – Sept (4 starts) of 2014: 5.73 ERA, 1.68 WHIP, 10.6 K/9

Samardzija is not as good as his number say they are. Everyone wanted to talk about trading him prior to the deadline in 2013 because of his outstanding numbers. Right around the start of July he became, at best, average.

Still not so sure? 2012, side-by-side again.

April/May (10 starts) of 2012: 3.09 ERA, 1.18 WHIP, 9.14 K/9
June – Sept (18 starts) of 2012: 4.48 ERA, 1.23 WHIP, 9.35 K/9

Sure, he started to strike out more guys. But there’s a trend here – and it seems to be trending in the wrong direction. The gap is widening between how Samardzija starts the year and how he ends it. He could very easily post a 4.5+ ERA with a 1.40 WHIP and a 9.0 K/9 for the rest of 2014.

Do you know what a 4.50 ERA, 1.40 WHIP, 9.0 K/9 pitcher looks like?

It looks like Tim Lincecum.

Okay, okay, fine. Samardzija will probably be better than Lincecum, but are you sure? His numbers don’t say he will be, and even if he is, it very likely won’t be by much. And is this the guy you all want to trade for as the savior in 2014.

Are you sure? Are you really, really sure? Especially when it is going to cost you – at minimum – two of your top prospects? When it’s going to cost you Kyle Crick and Edwin Escobar.

Listen, I’m all for the Giants making a move to bring someone in. I’m mostly happy to sell the farm and future for the here and now, but Samardzija is not the guy. His history shows it. He’s 29. He’s a right-hander. He starts seasons stronger than he finishes. These are all facts, and it’s beyond me that no one else seems to notice! Either that or no one cares – I don’t know which would be worse.

I predicted early on that the Giants would not make the playoffs this year. I noted that the Tim Hudson signing was a “bridge signing” – he’s here to help bring in the new wave of Giants pitchers. Crick, Escobar, Chris Stratton, this new kid Tyler Beede – they are the future and they’re almost here. We just have to be patient.

The Giants are off to a great start, but we’re already seeing them come back down to earth. They’re not a “best team in baseball” kind of team. Samardzija? Sure, he might help. Or he might just be another Lincecum. In any case, but he’s still not going to make them a “best team in baseball” kind of team.

And giving up two top prospects would be a rough way to find out.

Don’t forget to visit our SF Giants Rumors Facebook page to share your thoughts on all the latest Giants News/Rumors!

~Robert Barsanti

Want an email alert when there’s a new post? Click the “Contact Us” tab and request to be added to our email list. You can also follow on Twitter @SFGiants_Rumors, Google+, Pinterest and Instagram!

Technorati Tags: , , , , , , , , ,


  • David says:

    Let’s hope Sabean is beating the bushes for a franchise starter.

  • christian says:

    You’re not taking into account how a pitchers park like at&t will make samadzija’s splits look even better. Pitchers usually don’t start off with HOF numbers out the gate but Samadzija’s is coming into his prime and is breaking out. He can be a difference maker specially in the playoffs.

  • Dune says:

    You are also forgetting he pitches for an awful team. Pitched for the Cubs is bound to be tough for anyone over the course of a full season. Pitching for the Giants, well that’s a different story.

    Add to it the playoff hunt and the great culture in the San Francisco clubhouse and I would bet the farm that this guy will be a winner. Better than Lincecum? Yes. Able to help us? Yes.

    Could I be wrong? Yes. But because of Sabean’s track record with pitchers I believe the odds of him working out well are in the Giants favor if they decide to trade for him.

  • Dune says:

    I hate when I make mistakes. That should be pitching, not pitched, in the second sentence.

  • Robert says:

    Hey Dune,

    Haha I know what you mean – I hate it too. Noticed that I “bring” instead of “bringing” in the first paragraph and it’s killing me a little bit inside.


    I don’t disagree with any of the things you mentioned above, and yes, especially with pitching, “In Sabean We Trust.”

    I don’t doubt that Samardzija would benefit the Giants right away. What I do doubt is that he’ll be the difference maker we all want him to be.

    I also believe that he’s just overvalued by baseball in general. I think the Cubs know it, too, so… good for them. I don’t think he’s worth what the Cubs are going to ask (which, I assume is going to be at least two top of the line prospects). Especially with the Giants – their pitching is the only strength in the minors. Take away two of the top pitchers and you’re looking at one of the worst farms in the bigs.

    But, like you said, I could be wrong, also. Samardzija might come into SF and with the park and staff and culture here, get even better and help win a WS in 2014.

    I just don’t think that will be the case.

  • gpbutches says:

    They should be looking at Utley of the Phils as they’re about ready to have a fire sale an he’s only 9 mill a year an batting over 300

  • Mike says:

    Thank-you for the artical. Finally someone with sense. We should not give away top prospects for Samardzija. But if you want to talk David Price……