Why The Giants Should Not Be Concerned with Masahiro Tanaka

Masahiro Tanaka is the headliner at this year’s Free Agent pitcher concert. He’s easily grabbing the most attention and will undoubtedly grab the biggest contract. A lot of teams, including the San Francisco Giants, have expressed interest in the Japanese hurler, although as of today, it looks like those teams have been narrowed down to the New York Yankees, the Los Angeles Dodgers, and the Chicago Cubs (which one of these is not like the other?).


MasahiroTanakaAnd you know what? That’s fine. The Giants shouldn’t have their name anywhere near Tanaka’s. Sure, it’s public knowledge that the Giants want to add to and strengthen their rotation, but Tanaka is not the answer. And there are three main reasons why.


The posting fee for Tanaka is WAY too expensive.


Tanaka is expected to cost a posting fee at least equal to that of Yu Darvish – $51.7 million – and early reports were throwing around numbers between $75 and $100.


It’s true that the posting system previously in place has recently been cancelled and MLB is in talks with Japan for a new system, which could change this entirely in the next few weeks.


For now though, Tanaka is just too expensive, and that kind of money is something the Giants don’t need to commit to right now. Especially because…


The Giants have a talented crop of young pitchers just one year away from the bigs.


Assuming that all goes according to plan, or at least relatively close to plan, the Giants have righty Kyle Crick (#1 Giants prospect, #34*), lefty Clayton Blackburn (#2, #86), lefty Michael Kickham (#4) and Chris Stratton (#5) all (ideally) ready to go in 2015.


Sure, that means 2014 needs some help, but that is why the Giants have reportedly been focusing on some vets with low risk for low-paying contracts. Bronson Arroyo or Tim Hudson for two years is a perfect bridge into the new pitching SF Giants pitching rotation, providing stability and experience for the rising crop of arms.


That money is better spent on a power-hitting left fielder.


It’s not looking right now like the Giants will be able to pick up a big bat from this year’s Free Agent market, but that doesn’t mean they should be actively looking for an opportunity to trade. And in that situation, extra cash on hand could make or break a deal.


Given the perception that AT&T Park is where bats go to die, it’s been commonly accepted that the Giants will have to over-pay a big hitter to bring his lumber to the city by the bay. So start saving, Sabes.


Of course, the Giants may have many other reasons for wanting to or not wanting to pursue Tanaka. Recently it has become more and more clear that no, they won’t be making a push, and I believe that is the right choice.


Saving some money for a mid-season pick-up and bringing in experienced pitchers to help foster a new generation of arms is a great move, even if it means 2014 is another average season of middling play with no playoff appearances.


Just hold fast, fellow fans. Let Tanaka go to a team willing to spend $50 million just to sign another $75 million contract. The future is coming, and in 2015, it looks like Madison BumgarnerMatt Cain, Crick, Blackburn and Stratton.


*rankings are a combination of MLB’s 2013 Preseason rankings and Bleacher Report’s End of Season 2013 rankings


Don’t forget to visit our SF Giants Rumors Facebook page to share your thoughts on all the latest Giants News/Rumors!


~Robert Barsanti


Want an email alert when there’s a new post? Click the “Contact Us” tab and request to be added to our email list. You can also follow on Twitter @SFGiants_Rumors, and Google+!

Technorati Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,


  • mario says:

    they should sign Tanaka, he’s young and AT&T is a Pitchers park. they young arms are more of a risk and father down the line. they need to fill two spots and Tanaka should be one of themthen a veteran pitcher no Vogy either sign Vogy to a relief or AAA for depth. Plus the posting fee doesn’t count towards salary cap and they can make that back a couple times over in marketing.

  • Anthony says:

    Always a pleasure to read your articles King! I like your insights.

  • MIke E. says:

    Giants got to realize that in order to compete ( for a playoff spot or a chance in getting back to the world series) they have to spend money to get talent. The Giant’s strategy of going to the farm system tree to stock their team is starting to bear no fruit. We started to see that last year when there were no solid replacements for all the injuries to key players. And it showed with the abysmal second half. They probably can’t compete with the LA Dodgers money wise, but the Giants can be smart and look beyond their farm system to target talent in the international market to fill key spots like pitching and go after Tanaka.

  • Rony says:

    I say don’t even give Tanaka a second thought. The championship Giants were tweaked mid season to accommodate the existing parts. Keep the core They finally got “out” from the Barry Zito deal (still some $ owed) and there is no reason to sell the farm to get a hyped unproven (in the world market) pitcher. Spread the money out and compliment compliment compliment.

  • hcuebas says:

    Get a heavy hitter in the outfield, get the young guns(pitchers) on fast track and let’s go.